Securing Publish-Subscribe Architectures: Best Practices
Want to lock down your pub-sub system? Here's your quick guide:
- Verify users and apps
- Protect data in transit and at rest
- Secure your network
- Monitor everything
- Safeguard message brokers
- Implement client-side security
- Follow regulations
- Prepare for disasters
Quick Comparison:
| Security Aspect | Key Actions |
|---|---|
| User Verification | Strong logins, proper permissions |
| Data Protection | Encrypt in transit, manage keys |
| Network Security | Use firewalls, secure communication |
| Monitoring | Keep logs, regular security checks |
| Broker Protection | Tighten settings, group safely |
| Client Security | Safe setup, secure login handling |
| Compliance | Meet industry rules, follow specific steps |
| Disaster Prep | Make and test backup plans |
Remember: Security is ongoing. Stay alert, keep improving, and you'll build a fortress-strong pub-sub system.
Related video from YouTube
Key Security Risks in Publish-Subscribe Systems
Pub-sub systems are great, but they come with security challenges. Let's look at the main risks:
Common Weaknesses
Pub-sub systems often face these security issues:
- Unauthorized access
- Message interception
- Denial of Service (DoS)
- Data tampering
How Attackers Target Pub-Sub Systems
Cybercriminals use several methods to exploit pub-sub weaknesses:
1. Exploiting vulnerabilities in message brokers
Apache ActiveMQ recently faced a major threat. The CVE-2023-46604 vulnerability allowed remote code execution, putting thousands of systems at risk.
The Shadowserver Foundation reported over 7,000 internet-exposed ActiveMQ instances, with about 3,300 vulnerable to CVE-2023-46604 attacks.
2. Targeting access control flaws
Apache Kafka had a vulnerability (CVE-2024-27309) that could lead to unauthorized access during migrations.
3. Causing Out-of-Memory (OOM) conditions
Attackers can exploit vulnerabilities like CVE-2023-34455 in Apache Kafka to trigger OOM errors, potentially crashing the system.
4. Thread hijacking
This technique lets attackers intercept trusted conversations, potentially stealing data or credentials.
5. Malware delivery
Pub-sub systems can be used to deliver malware. The Antidot Trojan, for example, disguises itself as a Google Play update to establish a command-and-control channel.
| Attack Method | Description | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Vulnerability exploitation | Targeting known flaws in message brokers | Remote code execution, unauthorized access |
| OOM attacks | Causing memory exhaustion | System crashes, denial of service |
| Thread hijacking | Intercepting legitimate communications | Data theft, credential compromise |
| Malware delivery | Using pub-sub as a malware distribution channel | System infection, data exfiltration |
To protect your pub-sub system, you need to understand these risks and put strong security measures in place. We'll cover those next.
2. User and App Verification
Let's talk about keeping your pub-sub system locked down. It's all about making sure only the right folks and apps get in.
2.1. Strong Login Methods
You need rock-solid ways for users to log in. Here's the deal:
- API tokens: These are your go-to for machine-to-machine chats. Way safer than passwords. PubSub+ Cloud lets users whip up API tokens right in their console.
- Single Sign-On (SSO): Makes logging in a breeze and ups your security game. PubSub+ Cloud plays nice with OpenID Connect for SSO.
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA): It's like adding a security guard to your password.
2.2. Setting User Permissions
Once they're in, you've got to control what they can do:
- User roles: Think of these as different levels in a video game. PubSub+ Cloud uses roles to manage who can do what with event broker services.
- Least privilege principle: Only give users what they absolutely need. It's like giving someone a key to your house, but not your safe.
- Group-based access: It's easier to manage permissions for groups than individuals. Trust me, your future self will thank you.
Here's a quick look at some basic roles:
| Role | Permissions |
|---|---|
| Admin | Keys to the kingdom |
| Publisher | Can shout messages from specific rooftops |
| Subscriber | Can listen to specific channels |
| Monitor | Can look but can't touch |
- Access reviews: Regularly check who's got access to what. It's like spring cleaning for your permissions.
3. Protecting Data
Data security in pub-sub systems is crucial. Let's explore how to safeguard your information during transit and at rest.
3.1. Securing Data in Transit
When data's moving, it needs protection. Enter TLS/SSL:
- Use TLS/SSL always
- Configure it correctly
Google Cloud Pub/Sub has built-in security for message transport. But don't stop there.
"Google Cloud Pub/Sub always uses secure transport for messages and encrypts any stored pending messages."
3.2. Managing Security Keys
Keys are your data's gatekeepers. Here's how to handle them:
1. Use Customer-Managed Encryption Keys (CMEKs)
CMEKs offer more control. Quick setup:
# Create KMS key ring
gcloud kms keyrings create cc-pubsub-key-ring --location=global --project=cc-dataflow-project-123123
# Create CMEK
gcloud kms keys create cc-pubsub-topic-cmk --location=global --keyring=cc-pubsub-key-ring --purpose=encryption
# Create Pub/Sub topic with CMEK
gcloud pubsub topics create cc-encrypted-dataflow-topic --topic-encryption-key=projects/cc-dataflow-project-123123/locations/global/keyRings/ccc-pubsub-key-ring/cryptoKeys/cc-pubsub-topic-cmk
2. Encrypt Message Payloads
Protect your message content:
const crypto = require('crypto');
const data = 'Hello, world!';
const encryptedData = crypto.createHmac('sha256', key).update(data).digest('hex');
3. Rotate Keys Regularly
Change your keys on a schedule.
4. Limit Key Access
Restrict key access to those who need it.
4. Network Safety Measures
Let's talk about protecting your publish-subscribe system's network. We'll focus on firewalls and secure communication.
4.1. Setting Up Firewalls
Firewalls are your first defense against threats. Here's how to set them up:
1. Allow specific domains
For Google Cloud Pub/Sub, make sure your firewall allows:
- pubsub.googleapis.com
- type.googleapis.com
2. Use Virtual Private Clouds (VPCs)
Put your event broker services in a VPC. It's like giving your system its own private room, away from the public internet.
3. Implement network isolation
Keep your data separate from other cloud data. Google Cloud Pub/Sub can do this for you.
4. Configure public network rules
With Azure Web PubSub, you can control who gets in:
| Action | Configuration |
|---|---|
| No public traffic | Allow no request type |
| Only client connections | Allow client connections only |
5. Set up private endpoints
Give your pub-sub resource a private IP address. It's like having a secret phone number for your system.
4.2. Using Secure Communication
Now, let's make sure your data travels safely:
1. Use TLS/SSL
Always. It's like putting your data in an armored truck for transport.
2. Encrypt data at rest
Use strong encryption (AES-256) for stored data. Think of it as a high-tech safe for your information.
3. Use customer-managed encryption keys (CMEKs)
With Google Cloud Pub/Sub, you can manage your own keys. It's like being the only one with the combination to that safe.
4. Separate control and messaging planes
PubSub+ Cloud does this, encrypting both with AES-256 and TLS 1.2. It's like having two separate, secure channels for your system's brain and voice.
5. Regular security audits
Check your communication channels often. It's like giving your system regular health check-ups.
5. Watching for Issues
Keeping your publish-subscribe system secure means staying vigilant. Here's how to monitor effectively:
5.1. Keeping Detailed Records
Logging is crucial. It's your system's memory and your first line of defense. Here's how to do it right:
1. Set up comprehensive logging
Google Cloud Pub/Sub gives you detailed metrics. Use them:
| Metric | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Messages Count | Track message volume |
| Messages Size | Monitor unacknowledged message size |
| Oldest Message Age | Check message wait times |
These update every minute, giving you a real-time view.
2. Use audit logs
Audit logs are your system's black box. They show who did what and when. For example, PubSub+ Cloud logs:
- IAM operations
- User management
- Event broker service events
3. Forward logs to your monitoring system
Don't let logs sit idle. Use SysLog Forwarding to integrate them with your security tools.
5.2. Regular Security Checks
Frequent checks catch issues early. Here's how:
1. Set up automated alerts
Use Google Cloud's health signatures. They'll flag issues based on user impact.
2. Schedule regular reviews
Don't just wait for alerts. Review logs and metrics regularly. Look for odd patterns.
3. Check for misconfigurations
Watch for:
- Public resources
- Wrong IAM permissions
- Mishandled credentials
4. Monitor critical changes
Pay attention to changes in:
- Cloud Logging sinks
- Cloud Pub/Sub topics or subscriptions
These could blind you to system issues.
5. Test your defenses
Challenge your system's security. Even a tiny chance of breach (like 5.4 × 10⁻²⁰ for DDoS protection) is worth testing.
sbb-itb-96038d7
6. Protecting Message Brokers
Message brokers are crucial in publish-subscribe systems. Here's how to keep them safe:
6.1. Strengthening Broker Settings
To shield brokers from attacks:
-
Lock it down
- Use firewalls
- Block unnecessary protocols
- Open only needed ports (AMQP: 5671, MQTT: 8883)
-
Beef up authentication
- Use unique login credentials
- Set up Access Control Lists (ACLs)
- Ditch default settings
-
Encrypt everything
- TLS for all connections
- Encrypt message payloads
-
Stay vigilant
- Check logs often
- Update security patches ASAP
| Broker | Security Features |
|---|---|
| Apache Kafka | ACLs, TLS, SASL auth |
| RabbitMQ | TLS, LDAP, per-vhost control |
| ActiveMQ | SSL/TLS, JAAS, destination security |
6.2. Safe Broker Grouping
Group brokers smartly:
- Use a DMZ Put internet-facing brokers in a separate zone.
- Load balance Spread traffic across multiple brokers.
- Rate limit Cap messages per client to prevent flooding.
- Have backups Keep standby brokers ready.
- Secure broker talk Use mutual TLS for broker-to-broker communication.
Pro tip: Every broker in your group needs top-notch protection. One weak spot can bring down the whole system.
7. Client-Side Safety Steps
Let's talk about keeping clients safe in publish-subscribe systems. It's all about setting up clients right and handling login info securely.
7.1. Safe Client Setup
Want to prevent data leaks? Here's what to do:
-
Use Application Default Credentials (ADC)
- Install Google Cloud CLI
- Run
gcloud initandgcloud auth application-default login
-
Get authentication right
- Skip basic auth for production
- Go for LDAP-based auth or OAuth
-
Encrypt those message payloads
- Use keys only the right people can access
- Add message signatures to check integrity
-
Put IAM rules to work
- Give specific permissions at the resource level
- Control who can access Topics and Subscriptions
7.2. Handling Login Info Safely
Protect client login details like this:
-
Use short-lived credentials
- Set them to expire in 7 to 30 days
- Set up automatic rotation
-
Set up MQTT clients properly
- Get the broker hostname and port right
- Use a valid JSON Web Token (JWT) for the broker
-
Avoid mismatched credentials
- Make sure the Client ID matches the token
- Let Pub/Sub generate Client IDs or provide your own list
- Add extra security measures
| Measure | Description |
|---|---|
| Rate limiting | Use API Gateway between browser and IoT endpoint |
| Abuse detection | Think about services like GuardDuty |
| Topic restriction | Limit browser clients to one self-created topic |
"The most common failure case when connecting is supplying a mismatched Client ID and token."
8. Following Rules and Regulations
Setting up a publish-subscribe system? You need to play by the rules. Here's what you need to know:
8.1. Meeting Industry Standards
Different industries, different rules. Here are the big ones:
- GDPR: EU's data protection law. Break it? You could face fines up to €20 million or 4% of your global turnover.
- HIPAA: US health data rules. It's all about protecting health info.
- CCPA: California's privacy law. Residents can ask what data you're collecting and why.
These laws matter for pub-sub systems because they often handle personal data. Take GDPR: it says you must delete personal data within 30 days if asked. Tricky with append-only logs, right?
8.2. Specific Steps for Compliance
How to stay on the right side of the law:
1. Set a data retention policy
Don't hoard data. Keep it only as long as you need it.
2. Separate personal data
Keep it away from other data. Makes privacy compliance easier.
3. Use log compaction
Helps manage data. Make sure the last event in a sequence is personal-info-free.
4. Try crypto shredding
Instead of deleting data, remove the encryption keys. Helps meet data removal rules.
5. Enable resource logs
Turn on detailed logging for your pub-sub service. Helps track what's happening.
6. Get audited
Regular outside checks can catch issues before they blow up.
"Organizations must notify supervisory authorities and data subjects within 72 hours if a data breach affects users' personal information in most cases."
9. Preparing for Problems
Pub-sub systems can fail. Here's how to get ready:
9.1. Backup and Recovery Plans
Your system needs a solid backup. Do this:
1. Follow the 3-2-1 rule
Three copies, two storage types, one off-site. It's your safety net.
2. Set up replication
For ActiveMQ, try database replication. It's your Plan B.
3. Use MongoDB as backup
Send messages to Kafka and MongoDB. If Kafka drops the ball, MongoDB's got you covered.
Here's how:
from kafka import KafkaProducer
from pymongo import MongoClient
producer = KafkaProducer(bootstrap_servers=['localhost:9092'])
client = MongoClient('mongodb://localhost:27017/')
db = client['message_backup']
message = "Hello, Kafka!"
producer.send('my-topic', message.encode('utf-8'))
db.messages.insert_one({"message": message})
9.2. Testing Recovery Plans
Plans are good. Tested plans are better. Here's how:
1. Schedule regular tests
Test quarterly. Don't wait for disaster.
2. Simulate failures
Kill your primary system. Can your team handle it?
3. Time your recovery
How fast can you bounce back? If it's slow, fix it.
4. Automate where possible
Use scripts for tasks like promoting a slave to master in ActiveMQ. It's faster and safer.
"Back up your ActiveMQ data and config files regularly. For persistent messages, back up the database or KahaDB/JDBC persistence store."
Conclusion
Securing pub-sub systems is an ongoing job. Here's what we've covered:
1. User and app checks
Use strong logins and set the right permissions.
2. Data protection
Keep data safe in transit and manage security keys well.
3. Network safety
Use firewalls and secure communication.
4. Monitoring
Keep logs and do regular security checks.
5. Message broker protection
Tighten broker settings and group safely.
6. Client-side security
Set up clients safely and handle logins securely.
7. Compliance
Meet industry rules and follow specific steps.
8. Disaster prep
Make and test backup plans.
These steps are a good start, but threats change. To stay safe:
- Update software quickly
- Do regular audits
- Use encryption
- Control access
Your security duties depend on how you deploy. For PubSub+ Cloud:
| Deployment Type | Who Handles Security |
|---|---|
| Public Regions | Solace |
| Dedicated Regions | Solace |
| Customer-Controlled Regions | Customer |
In customer-controlled setups, work with your teams on permissions and monitoring.
Remember: Security never stops. Stay alert and keep improving.
FAQs
What are the best practices for high cloud pub sub availability?
Want to keep your cloud pub/sub system running smoothly? Here's what you need to know:
1. Attach subscriptions early
Don't wait! Hook up a subscription or turn on topic retention before you start publishing. This way, you won't lose any messages.
2. Use batch messaging
Batch your messages. It's like carpooling for data - more efficient and less traffic on the network.
3. Implement flow control
Set up flow control. It's like a traffic cop for your messages, keeping things moving when there's a sudden rush.
4. Understand network limits
Know your network's strengths and weaknesses. It's like knowing the speed limit on your daily commute - helps you avoid getting stuck.
5. Optimize retry settings
Tweak your retry settings for failed publishes. It's like giving your system a second (or third) chance to get it right.
Here's a quick look at why these practices matter:
| Practice | Why it's important |
|---|---|
| Early subscription | Keeps your messages safe |
| Batch messaging | Makes delivery smoother |
| Flow control | Handles sudden message floods |
| Network awareness | Stops traffic jams before they start |
| Retry optimization | Gives your system another shot at success |
Related posts
Ready to get started?
