7 Best RBAC Tools for SaaS Applications 2024

by Endgrate Team 2024-10-29 16 min read

Need to control who can access what in your SaaS apps? Here's a quick breakdown of the top RBAC tools:

Tool Best For Starting Price
Okta Identity Cloud Large enterprises, 7000+ integrations $2/user/month
Azure AD Microsoft ecosystem users Free with Office 365
CyberArk Identity Security-focused companies Custom pricing
SailPoint IdentityNow Mid to large companies Custom pricing
Endgrate API-first companies, 100+ integrations Free tier available
OneLogin Small-medium teams $2/user/month
JumpCloud Multi-OS environments Tiered pricing

Key Features All Tools Share:

  • Single Sign-On (SSO)
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)
  • Role-based permissions
  • Audit logging
  • API access control

Quick Comparison:

Tool Integration Count Security Level Setup Complexity
Okta 7,000+ High Complex
Azure AD 3,000+ High Medium
CyberArk 500+ Very High Complex
SailPoint 1,000+ High Medium
Endgrate 100+ Medium Easy
OneLogin 2,000+ Medium Easy
JumpCloud 700+ High Medium

Pick Okta or Azure AD for enterprise-grade security, OneLogin for smaller teams, or JumpCloud if you need to manage different types of devices. Want API power? Go with Endgrate.

Okta Identity Cloud: Core Features and Uses

Okta Identity Cloud

Okta Identity Cloud is a web-based SSO system that lets users access multiple apps through one dashboard. Since 2009, it's been helping companies manage user access and permissions.

Here's what you get with Okta:

Feature Description Benefit
SSO Integration Connect to Gmail, Office 365, Salesforce Log into 6,500+ apps at once
Multi-Factor Auth OTP, push alerts, biometrics Better security
Policy Engine Set permissions by job/department Control who sees what
Session Security Location checks (ASN/IP) for admins Stops token theft
Workflows Auto user setup/removal Less manual work

The pricing breaks down like this:

Plan Type Cost per User/Month What You Get
Basic SSO $2 Core login features
MFA $3 Extra security tools
Adaptive SSO $5 Smart access rules
Adaptive MFA $6 Top-level protection

Heads up: You'll need to spend at least $1,500/year.

Security That Works:

  • DPoP comes standard for API connections
  • Admin sessions tied to location
  • Full activity tracking
  • Zero Trust built-in

Here's How It Works: Let's say you're a super admin at ExampleCorp. Setting up Workflows looks like this:

1. Make admin groups

2. Connect user info to Workflows

3. Hand out roles (Admin, Auditor, Connection Manager)

4. Set up automatic onboarding

Okta does three things really well:

What It Does How It Helps
Access Control Manages roles, permissions, and monitoring
Security Protects tokens, checks locations, spots risks
Reports Tracks usage, flags issues, analyzes logs

Want to use Okta? Start here:

  • List your current systems
  • Define your roles
  • Plan your integrations
  • Build your workflows
  • Watch how people use it

If you need RBAC with SSO that just works, Okta Identity Cloud fits the bill.

2. Azure AD: Microsoft's Access Control Solution

Azure AD

Azure AD is Microsoft's cloud platform that manages who gets into your apps and data. Think of it as a digital bouncer that checks IDs and decides who can do what.

Here's what you get with Azure AD:

Feature What It Does
SSO Integration Links to 3,300+ apps with one login
Identity Protection Spots and blocks weird login attempts
Access Management Controls who does what
Multi-Factor Auth Makes users prove it's really them
Audit Logging Records who did what and when

Here's what it costs:

Plan Cost/User/Month What You Get
Office 365 Included Basic ID controls
Premium P1 $6 More admin tools
Premium P2 $9 Advanced security + PIM

Azure AD comes with ready-to-use roles:

Role What They Can Do Who Uses It
Global Admin Everything IT bosses
User Admin Handle users HR people
Reader Look but don't touch Auditors
Custom Roles Whatever you need Special cases

The Numbers You Need to Know:

  • 2,000 role assignments per subscription
  • 500 role assignments per management group
  • 100 built-in roles to pick from

Setting It Up Is Simple:

  1. Pick where it applies
  2. Choose your roles
  3. Give them to people
  4. Watch what happens

Make It Work Better:

  • Use the roles that come with it
  • Put people in groups
  • Keep an eye on who does what
  • Clean up old permissions

Extra Security Stuff:

  • Lock down admin accounts
  • Set time limits on access
  • Watch for weird behavior
  • Pull reports when needed

If you're already using Microsoft tools or need serious access control, Azure AD fits right in. It's like having a super-smart security guard who never sleeps and follows your exact instructions.

3. CyberArk Identity: Security-First RBAC

CyberArk Identity

CyberArk Identity puts security at the core of access management. Here's what you'll get:

Feature Category What You Get
Core Security • MFA and passwordless login
• SSO for web and mobile apps
• Real-time threat detection
Access Control • Custom role definitions
• Policy-based permissions
• Automated access provisioning
Integration • Active Directory sync
• Azure AD connection
• API access management
Monitoring • User activity tracking
• Access pattern analysis
• Security alerts

The platform connects with 100+ pre-built apps, offers MFA and passwordless authentication, and syncs with AD, Azure AD, and custom directories.

Here's how it works:

1. User Management

The system pulls data from your directories (like Active Directory) and keeps everything in sync - no manual work needed.

2. Access Setup

You'll set up roles and policies based on:

  • What people do
  • Which department they're in
  • How much access they need
  • What devices they use

3. Security Measures

You get protection through:

  • MFA for admin access
  • Time limits on access
  • Rules for specific devices
  • Watching how apps get used
Plan Type Best For Main Features
Basic Small teams SSO, basic roles
Business Mid-size companies Custom roles, MFA
Enterprise Large organizations Full security suite

Want better security? Here's what to do:

  • Turn on MFA for anyone with admin access
  • Start with the pre-built app templates
  • Look at your access logs every week
  • Clean up old accounts once a month

CyberArk Identity fits companies that want tight security and single-point control. It's perfect if you're running Active Directory or Azure AD.

Users give it 4.22 out of 5 stars - proof that it delivers on both security and access management.

4. SailPoint IdentityNow: Cloud-Based Access Control

SailPoint IdentityNow

SailPoint IdentityNow combines AI and machine learning to handle identity security in hybrid IT environments. Here's what you get:

Feature Category Capabilities
Access Control • Two-tier role modeling (Business & IT Roles)
• Self-service access requests
• Auto-provisioning and de-provisioning
Security • AI-powered risk detection
• Real-time access monitoring
• Password policy enforcement
Compliance • Detailed audit reports
• Access certification
• Policy management
Integration • Cloud platform support (Azure, AWS, GCP)
• Out-of-box connectors
• API access management

The platform's role-based system makes it stand out. Here's how it works:

1. Business Roles

The system sets up common roles like Manager or Security Analyst. Users get their access instantly when assigned a role.

2. Access Management

Process How It Works
User Joins Auto-creates accounts and sets permissions
Role Change Updates access based on new position
User Leaves Removes all access immediately
Regular Review Checks and updates permissions as needed

3. AI at Work

The AI engine:

  • Spots access patterns
  • Flags suspicious behavior
  • Helps with access decisions
  • Compares permissions across peer groups

"With SailPoint, we now have a solution that also is harmonious with our cloud-first strategy."

Kim Valois, CISO at Flinders University
User Rating Category Percentage
Excellent 55%
Very Good 40%
Average 5%
Poor 0%
Terrible 0%

Want the best results? Here's what to do:

  • Start with both business and IT teams
  • Give department heads control over team access
  • Schedule regular access reviews
  • Follow AI suggestions for role changes

"The certification module is perhaps one of the most valuable features. The options are pretty intuitive and you can usually set up the certification easily without much time or resource investment."

Senior Manager at a consultancy with 10,001+ employees

This tool fits best with large organizations that need strong identity controls and can handle a detailed setup process.

sbb-itb-96038d7

5. Endgrate: Integration-Focused Access Management

Endgrate

Endgrate simplifies RBAC by putting integrations first. Their API lets you control permissions across 100+ connected services from one place.

Here's what you get:

Access Control Features Description
Integration Management Control access rights across 100+ third-party services
Single API Control Manage all integration permissions from one dashboard
Custom Data Models Set specific permissions for different data types
Security Standards Top-level security for all connections

The RBAC system breaks down into three parts:

1. Integration Access Levels

Think of these as permission tiers. Each level controls what users can do:

Level Controls
Admin Full integration setup and user management
Manager Integration settings and team access
User Basic integration use with preset limits
Read-only Can only view integration data

2. Permission Settings

These are your day-to-day controls:

Category Capabilities
Data Access Pick what integration data users see and change
Function Access Control which features each role can use
Time Limits Set when contractor access starts and stops
IP Restrictions Lock access to specific networks

3. Integration Management

Here's how you keep everything running smoothly:

Feature Function
API Keys Create and handle access tokens
Usage Tracking See how people use integrations
Audit Logs Keep tabs on permission changes
Bulk Controls Update many services at once

You can pick from three plans:

  • Free: Basic integration access
  • Standard: Team-based permission management
  • Premium: Advanced security features

Endgrate fits best if you're juggling lots of third-party services and want ONE place to manage them all. It's built for companies that connect to many external tools and need tight control over who can do what.

6. OneLogin: Single Sign-On and Access Control

OneLogin

OneLogin leads the Identity and Access Management space with 21,448 customers and 49.57% market share. Here's what their RBAC system does:

Core Features Description
Dynamic Provisioning Sets up users in workspaces/roles based on their info
Just-in-Time Access Adds users when they first log in with work email
API Controls Manages roles and permissions in bulk
Multi-Factor Auth Adds login security checks
User Lifecycle Handles user access across all apps

OneLogin's access control works in 4 main areas:

Access Level What It Does
User Management Creates and manages roles and groups
App Access Sets which users can use each app
Security Rules Limits access by IP and time
Audit Tracking Logs who does what and when

The system has 3 main parts:

1. Role Assignment

OneLogin handles roles through:

  • Login-time syncs
  • Manual assignments
  • Bulk API updates

2. Access Rules

Rule Type What It Controls
Workspace Rules Who gets in based on user info
Role Mapping Which roles users get
Time Windows When users can access systems
Network Rules Which networks can connect

3. Pricing

Plan Monthly Cost Per User
SSO $2
MFA $2
Enterprise Contact sales

OneLogin fits best if you:

  • Need one login for many apps
  • Want to automate user setup
  • Need SOC 2 and ISO 27001 compliance
  • Have lots of different roles

With over 2,000 customers worldwide, OneLogin keeps things simple while staying secure. It works with both cloud and local apps through a single login.

7. JumpCloud: Directory-as-a-Service with RBAC

JumpCloud

JumpCloud combines identity management and unified endpoint management into one cloud platform. Let's break down what their RBAC system does:

Feature Description
SSO Integration Works with AD, Entra, Google, Okta at no extra cost
MFA Security Built-in multi-factor authentication
Device Management Controls access across Windows, macOS, Linux, mobile
Zero Trust Environment-wide MFA with conditional access rules
SCIM Support Automates user attributes and role assignments

Here's how their admin roles work:

Role Type Access Level Capabilities
Admin with Billing Full All system controls + billing
Administrator High All system controls except billing
Manager Medium User, device, group management
Help Desk Limited Password resets, user creation
Read Only Basic View-only access to resources

The platform works through 3 main parts:

1. Identity Management

JumpCloud handles the basics: adding/removing users, managing groups, setting access rights, and updating permissions.

2. Access Controls

Control Type Function
Dynamic Groups Auto-validates user/device entitlements
Custom Roles Granular permission settings
Resource Access Repository-level controls
API Management Access token administration

3. Security Features

Feature Purpose
Pre-built Policies Ready-made compliance templates
Device Trust Zero Trust device verification
Audit Logging Track access and changes
Lifecycle Rules Automated access updates

JumpCloud works best if you:

  • Need a cloud directory service
  • Want to automate user management
  • Need to control multiple device types
  • Care about Zero Trust security

Tool Comparison

Here's a breakdown of the top RBAC tools and what makes each one different:

Tool Core Focus Best For Pricing Model
Okta Identity Cloud Enterprise IAM Large organizations Custom pricing
Azure AD Cloud-first IAM Microsoft ecosystem Tiered, starts free
CyberArk Identity Security & PAM Security-focused teams GPL-3.0 license
SailPoint IdentityNow Cloud Access Control Mid to large enterprises Custom pricing
Endgrate Integration Management API-first companies Free to Premium tiers
OneLogin SSO & Access Small to mid-size teams Per-user pricing
JumpCloud Directory Services Multi-OS environments Tiered pricing

Let's look at what each tool can connect with:

Tool Cloud Services On-Premise Third-Party Apps
Okta AWS, GCP, Azure Yes 7,000+
Azure AD Azure-focused Yes 3,000+
CyberArk Jenkins, Puppet Yes 500+
SailPoint Major clouds Limited 1,000+
Endgrate 100+ integrations No API-based
OneLogin Major clouds Limited 2,000+
JumpCloud AD, Entra, Google Yes 700+

Here's what security features each tool offers:

Feature Okta Azure AD CyberArk SailPoint Endgrate OneLogin JumpCloud
MFA
SSO
Zero Trust Limited Limited
API Security Limited
Audit Logs

Speed and scale matter - here's how the tools perform:

Tool Authorization Speed Scalability User Capacity
OpenFGA < 1ms High Unlimited
Permify < 10ms High Custom
Oso < 50ms Medium Per plan
Casbin < 5ms High Unlimited

And here's what the open-source community thinks:

Tool Stars License Active Contributors
Casdoor 8,685 Apache-2.0 High
Zitadel 7,170 Apache-2.0 Medium
Cerbos 2,533 Apache-2.0 Medium
Permit 2,306 Apache-2.0 Medium

Bottom line: Okta and Azure AD pack the most features for big companies. JumpCloud works great if you need to manage different types of devices. If you want to build your own system, open-source tools like Casbin give you that freedom.

Summary and Recommendations

Here's a no-nonsense guide to picking the right RBAC tool for your SaaS setup:

Business Type Best Tool Choice Why It Fits
Large Enterprise Okta Identity Cloud 7,000+ integrations + top-tier security
Microsoft Users Azure AD Works perfectly with Microsoft, free to start
Security-First CyberArk Identity Built for high-security access control
Mid-Size Business SailPoint IdentityNow Born in the cloud, hits the sweet spot
API-Focused Endgrate 100+ API connections, modern stack
Small Teams OneLogin Simple pricing, 2,000+ tools connect
Mixed OS Environment JumpCloud Handles all devices, all platforms

Here's What Matters Most:

1. Integration Check

Your tech stack needs to play nice with your RBAC tool. Look at:

  • Current tool compatibility
  • API options for custom needs
  • Room to grow as you scale

2. Security Must-Haves

Every tool has MFA, but they're not all equal:

  • Okta, Azure AD, and CyberArk lead in Zero Trust
  • API security varies (see our comparison table)
  • Each tool has different security extras

3. Money Talk

What to Look At Why It Matters
User Count Some charge per person, others flat rate
Features Basic vs premium - big price gap
Support Often costs extra
Training Don't skip this in your budget

Getting Started:

  • Lock down your most important systems first
  • List out your roles BEFORE you switch
  • Test with a small group
  • Keep roles simple
  • Set up alerts from day one

Bottom Line: Okta and Azure AD are the heavy hitters. Smaller teams? Check out OneLogin or JumpCloud - they're cheaper and easier to use. Need API power? Endgrate's your best bet with 100+ ready-to-go integrations.

Don't skip the audit trails - they're your safety net. Every tool here logs activity, but storage time and detail level change between them.

Pick This If You Want
Okta Big business security + tons of connections
Azure AD Perfect Microsoft fit
CyberArk Security on steroids
SailPoint Pure cloud power
Endgrate API connection king
OneLogin Easy + budget-friendly
JumpCloud Works on all systems

FAQs

What is RBAC management platform?

An RBAC (Role-Based Access Control) management platform controls who can access what in your system based on their job roles.

Here's how it works:

Component Function
Roles Define access levels by job type
Permissions Set specific actions allowed
Users Get matched to roles

Let's look at a real healthcare example:

Role Access Level What They Can Do
Doctor Full medical access See all records, order tests, prescribe meds
Nurse Basic medical access Check vitals, write care notes
Admin Business access only Book appointments, handle billing

The numbers show why RBAC matters:

26% of SaaS security problems come from inside threats. That's why many companies use Microsoft Active Directory for RBAC.

"Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) is a method of access control that assigns permissions to users based on their roles within an organization."

Minu Joseph, Product Marketer

Here's what RBAC does for you:

  • Reduces admin tasks
  • Makes security checks simple
  • Keeps data on a need-to-know basis
  • Connects with your Microsoft tools

Want to set up RBAC? Do this:

  1. Write down your job roles
  2. Pick what each role can do
  3. Start simple
  4. Add more rules as you need them

Related posts

Ready to get started?

Book a demo now

Book Demo